. I THE ALDINE EDITION OF THE BRITISH POETS r THE POETICAL WORKS OP MARK AKENSIDE THE POETICAL WORKS OF MARK AKENSIDE S*H - v%J4S5V v3s-^s^ •v-£l LONDON BELL AND DALDY YORK STREET COVENT GARDEN k s . / ADVERTISEMENT. //*/ IprAHE present edition of Akenside's Poetical Works is substantially that prepared in 1834, by the Rev. -ander Dyce, for Pickering's " Aldine Edition of the British Poets. " The elegant Memoir which lie prefixed is given entire, and the few additions which seemed neces- sary, have been appended as notes. Every poem which could be traced to the author's pen has been inserted; each, except The Pleasures of Imagination, has been printed from the edition which received the last re- vision of the author ; and by strictly ad- hering to it the greatest accuracy has been secured. " The Pleasures of Imagination' is here printed as first issued in 1744, and also as enlarged and published by Mr. Dyson, in 1772. ADVERTISEMENT. The Odes and Miscellaneous Poems have also been printed from Mr. Dyson's edition, with the exception of Ode ii. Book n., which is taken from " Pearch's Collection of Poems ;" " An Epistle to Curio" from the edition of 1744; " The Virtuoso" " Ambition and Content" " The Poet" " A British Phi- lippic" and " A Hymn to Science" from the " Gentleman's Magazine;'' " Love, an Elegy " from " The New Foundling Hospital for Wit;" " To Cordelia," from an edition of Akenside's Works, published at New Bruns- wick, in 1808 ; mi" A Song," from " Ritson's English Songs/' vol. i. The date and man- ner of its first appearance has been added to each of those published during the author's lifetime. By the kind permission of Mr. Murray of Albemarle-street, three valuable letters, not included in the former edition, have been in- serted as an appendix to Mr. Dyce's Memoir of the Poet. CONTENTS. I IFE of Akenside, by the Rev. Alex- ander Dyce The Pleasures of Imagination. In three Books. The Design Book I II Ill Notes on Book I II V . . . . Ill The Pleasures of the Imagination. On an enlarged plan. General Argument Book I II Ill IV Odes on several Subjects. In two Books. Book I. Ode I. Preface II. On the Winter Solstice . . Ditto. As originally written III. To a Friend, unsuccessful in Love IV. Affected Indifference V. Against Suspicion . . VI. Hymn to Cheerfulness . VII. On the Use of Poetry . VIII. On leaving Holland IX. To Curio X. To the Muse .... XI. On Love, to a Friend XII. To Sir Francis Henry Drake, bart. . . . XIII. On Lyric Poetry . . Paze 1 5 23 46 65 70 74 83 84 106 127 143 147 149 153 155 157 158 161 166 167 171 177 178 181 1S4 CONTENTS. Odes ok several Subjects. Pace Book I. Ode XIV. To the Hon. Charles Towns- hend 188 XV. To the Evening Star . . 190 XVI. To Caleb Hardinge, M.D. 193 XVII. On a Sermon against Glory 195 XVIII. To the Earl of Huntingdon 196 Book II. Ode I. The Remonstrance of Shake- speare 205 II. To Sleep 208 III, To the Cuckoo ..... 211 IV. To the Hon. Charles Towns- hend 212 V. On Love of Praise . . . . 218 VI. To William Hall, Esq. . . 220 VII. To the Bishop of Winchester 222 VIII 225 IX. At Study 226 X. To Thomas Edwards, Esq. . 228 XI. To the Country Gentlemen of England 230 XII. On recovering from a Eit of Sickness 236 XIII. To the Author of Memoirs of the House of Bran.denburgh . 239 XIV. The Complaint 241 XV. On Domestic Manners . . 242 Notes on the Two Books of Odes 244 Hymn to the Naiads 248 Notes on the Hymn to the Naiads . . . . . 259 Inscriptions 268 An Epistle to Curio '. . . . 275 The Virtuoso 286 Ambition and Content. A Eable 289 The Poet. A Rhapsody 293 A British Philippic 298 Hymn to Science 303 Love, an Elegy 306 To Cordelia 310 Song 311 THE LIFE OF AKENSIDE/ BY THE REV. ALEXANDER DYCE. I ARK AKENSIDE2 was born at New- castle - upon - Tyne, iSToveniber 9th, 1721, and was baptized on the 30th of the same month by the minister of a meeting-house, which his parents used to frequent.3 His father, Mark, was a respectable butcher.4 His mother's maiden name was Mary 1 During the earlier years of his life, the poet spelt his name, both on the title pages of his publications and in his letters, Akinside; but at a later period he adopted the form Akenside. 2 "Mark Akenside, born the 9th November, 1721: baptized ye 30th of the same month by the Rev. Mr. Benjamin Bennet." — History of Newcastle, ii. 513, by Brand, who adds : " The above was communicated by Mr. Addison, glazier, at Newcastle-upon-Tyne, who mar- ried Dr. Akenside's sister, and is in possession of some drawings, which, were the works of that ingenious poet in an early period of his life. Mr. Bennet was a dissenting minister at the new meeting-house in Hanover Square*, Newcastle-upon-Tyne." 3 According to the Blog, Brit., Akenside's " parents and relations were in general of the Presbyterian persua- sion." 4 " The Akenside family belonged to Eachwick in Northumberland ; but his father was a reputable butcher b 11 LIFE OF AKENSIDE. Lumsden.1 He was their second son. It is said that in after life he was ashamed of the lowness of his birth, which was constantly brought to his recollection by a lameness, originating in a cut on his foot from the fall of his father's cleaver, when he was about seven years old. After receiving some instruction at the free- school of Newcastle, he was sent to a private aca- demy in the same town, kept by a Mr. Wilson, a dissenting minister. His genius, and his love of poetry, were mani- fested, while he was yet a school-boy. The Gentle- man's Magazine for April, 1737, contains one of his earliest attempts at versification, entitled The Virtuoso, in imitation of Spenser's style and stanza :3 it is far superior to the sing-song inanities, which in those days generally adorned the pages of that miscellany, and is prefaced thus by a letter to the editor : " Newcastle upon Tyne, April, 23. (i I hope, Sir, you'll excuse the following Poem, (being the Performance of one in his sixteenth year), and insert it in your next Magazine, which will oblige. Yours &c. " Marcus." To the same popular work he contributed, in the next month, an ingenious fable called Ambition in the Butcher-bank, Newcastle." Richardson's Local Historian's Table Book, ii. 184, where is an engraving of the house in which Akenside was born. Ed. 1 "1710, August 10, Mark Akenside and Mary Lums- den, mar." — Register of St. Nicholas, Neivcastle. Ed. 2 Brand's Obs, on Pop. Antiq. 114, ed. 1777. 3 Vol. vii. 244. — Mr. Bucke thinks it was suggested by a passage in Shaftesbury's Characteristics, iii. 156. ed. 1737- Life of Akenside, 5 . LIFE OF AKENSIDE. ill and Content ; and, in July following, The Poet, a Rhapsody. When about the age of seventeen, Akenside used to visit some relations at Morpeth, where it has been rather hastily supposed that he wrote his Pleasures of Imagination.1 Passages of it were, probably, composed there : at various times and places, during several years before its publication, that great work had, no doubt, occupied his mind. In a fragment of the fourth book of the remodelled copy,2 he pleasingly describes his early sensibility to the beauties of nature, and his lonely wander- ings in the vicinity both of Newcastle and of Morpeth. To the Gentleman s Magazine for August, 1738,3 he communicated A British Philippic, occasioned by the insults of the Spaniards, and the present pre- 'parations for war. That its flaming patriotism was quite to the taste of Mr. Urban, appears from the following advertisement : " X. B. It often turning to our Inconvenience to sell a greater Number of one Magazine than of another, and believing the above noble-spirited Poem will be acceptable to many, not our constant Headers, we have printed it in Folio, Price Six Pence, together with the Motto at large, for which, receiving the Manuscript late, we could not make room. And if the ingenious Author will inform us how we may direct a Packet to his Hands, we will send him our Acknowledgments for so great a Favour with a Parcel of the Folio Edition." His Hymn to Science was printed in the Gentle- Biog. Brit. Ver. 31—45, page 144. Vol, viii. 427, where it is signed " BritannicusJ IV LIFE OF AKENSIDE. man's Magazine for October, 1739.1 It is doubt- less a production of considerable merit ; but Mr. Bucke is probably the only reader whom it ever moved to rapturous admiration. Our poet was about eighteen years of age when he was sent to Edinburgh, with some pecuniary assistance from the Dissenters' Society, that he might qualify himself for the office of one of their ministers ; but, after pursuing the requisite studies for one winter, he changed his mind with respect to a profession, entered himself a medical student,2 and repaid the contribution Which he had received from the Dissenters. " Whether," says Johnson, " when he resolved not to be a dissenting minister, he ceased to be a dissenter, I know not. He cer- tainly retained an unnecessary and outrageous zeal for what he called and thought liberty ; a zeal which sometimes disguises from the world, and not rarely from the mind which it possesses, an envious desire of plundering wealth or degrading greatness ; and of which the immediate tendency 1 Vol. ix. 544, where it is dated "Newcastle upon Tyne." Mr. Bucke, not aware of this, supposes that it was written at Edinburgh. He pronounces it {Life of Akenside, 19) to be " worthy the lyre of Collins," to whose imaginative odes it bears no resemblance ; and after quoting stanzas 12 and 13 (page 305), exclaims, " Has Horace or Gray anything superior to this ?" I confidently answer, — many things infinitely superior. In the same vol. of the Gent Mag. p. 1 53, is An Imitation of Horace, Ode I. B. hi,, signed " M. A." Qy. Is it by Akenside? When the Pleasures of Imagination appeared, the editor of the Gent. Mag,, xiv. 219., gave an extract from that poem, headed by an announcement that it was written by the author of the British Philippic and the Hymn to Science. 2 In a letter written from Newcastle, in 1742 (given at page vii), he calls himself " Surgeon." LIFE OF AKENSIDE. V is innovation and anarchy, an impetuous eagerness to subvert and confound, with very little care what shall be established."1 At Edinburgh he was elected a member of the Medical Society, December 30th, I740,2 and be- came acquainted with several persons of his own age, who afterwards rose to eminence ; but though, during his residence there, he prosecuted the study of medicine,3 we learn from the following authentic statement that he was by no means satisfied with his new profession, and thirsted for a celebrity very different from that which its most successful practice could confer. " Akenside," says the late Dugald Stewart, " when a student at Edinburgh, was a member of the Medical Society, then re- cently formed, and was eminently distinguished by the eloquence which he displayed in the course of the debates. Dr. Robertson (who was at that time a student of divinity in the same university) told me that he was frequently led to attend their meetings, chiefly to hear the speeches of Akenside ; the great object of whose ambition then was a seat in Parliament ; a situation which, he was sanguine enough to flatter himself, he had some prospect of obtaining ; and for which he conceived his talents to be much better adapted than for the profession he had chosen. In this opinion he was probably in the right, as he was generally considered by his fellow-students as far inferior in medical science 1 Life of Akenside. 2 Anderson's Life of Akenside. — Brit. Poets, ix. 725. 3 Mr. Bucke says that Akenside " seems to have made great progress" in his medical studies at Edinburgh (Life of Akenside, 16), and in quoting from Stewart the passage which I have given above, he omits the concluding sen- tence. VI LIFE OF AKENSIDE. to several of his companions."1 To the ardour of youth, and the consciousness of high endowments, we ought probably to attribute such ambitious dreams ; and we may suppose, that as judgment ripened with maturer years, they faded gradually away. At Edinburgh he composed his ode On the Winter Solstice, dated 1740, which he soon after re-wrote and amplified. He is said2 to have ori- ginally printed it with another juvenile production, Love, an Elegy, for distribution among his friends. His lines To Cordelia bear the same date. We are told by Akenside's biographers, that after staying three years at Edinburgh, he removed to Leyden for the advancement of his medical studies : — that he remained there two (according 1 Elem, of the Phil, of the Human Mind (Notes), iii. 501. 4to. The author is led to give the above anecdote by having quoted in his text (p. 299) the following lines in Akenside's Ode to Sleep, where, he observes, the poet " has very beautifully touched upon the history of his own mind : " " The figured brass, the choral song, The rescued people's glad applause, The listening senate, and the laws Fixed by the counsels of Timoleon's tongue, Are scenes too grand for fortune's private ways ; And, though they shine in youth's ingenuous view, The sober gainful arts of modern days To such romantic thoughts have bid a long adieu." 2 Biog. Brit. — In the Ad. and Cor. to the first vol. we are told that Love " afterwards appeared in the first edition of Dodsley's Collection, but was omitted in succeeding editions by Akenside's desire." It certainly is not in the first ed. of that work, 3 vols. 1748, but may have been inserted in some early edition of those, or the subsequently- published volumes, which I have not seen : it was printed in the third volume of Pearch's Coll. of Poems. LIFE OF AKENSIDE. Vll to others, three) years, till he had taken his degree of Doctor of Physic, in 1744: — that he there formed an intimacy with his future patron, Mr. Jeremiah Dyson,1 then a student of law at the same univer- sity, and returned with him to England — (they " embarked," according to Mr. Bucke's2 particular account, " in the same vessel at Rotterdam, and arrived safely in London, after an agreeable but protracted voyage !"): — and that the Pleasures of Imagination was published soon after the poet's arrival in England. I shall presently show that Akensides first and only visit to Leyden was in 1744, and subsequent to the appearance of his great work ; and that he and Mr. Dyson were never in Holland at the same time. Having completed his studies in the Scottish capital, Akenside appears to have returned to his native town in 1741. Next year, he addressed the following remarkable letter3 to Mr. Dyson, a young gentleman of fortune, with whom, perhaps, he had become acquainted during his residence in Edin- burgh : " Newcastle upon Tyne, ye 18th of Augst, 1742. " Dear Sir, " I have been long expecting to hear from you since I had the pleasure of seeing you on the road : but your letter has either miscarry'd or has been prevented perhaps by some unexpected affairs ingaging you after your arrival at London longer than you suppos'd. Upon either of these cases I should not have delay'd to begin a correspondence sooner, but that I knew not how to direct for you. Our acquaintance, Mr. Anderson, has just now inform'd me ; and I take the opportunity of his journey 1 On the authority, I suppose, of Sir John Hawkins. — Life of Johnson, 233, 243, ed. 1787. 2 Life of Akenside, 24. 3 Now first published. Viil LIFE OF AKENSIUE. to London to send you this. For where there is a real esteem and affection, it is certainly extremely absurd to act according to those precisenesses of form and punctu- ality, which in some matters may prevent inconvenience, but can never regulate the mind, and have no connection with the free inclinations of one who would be a friend. The very opportunity of knowing a person of a desirable character, is the means of no slight enjoyment; but the prospect of contracting a friendship in such a case brings the pleasure much nearer home, and promises a kind of property in those things which all men look upon with honour and good wishes. If you will excuse me for being thus selfish, I sincerely and heartily offer you my friend- ship ; and tho' in such a compact, where there are no articles of obligation, nothing stipulated, nothing imposed, it be not very becoming to promise too much, yet I think one may venture to ingage for himself, that he is capable of being a friend : for tho' in our voluntary affairs this be indeed the main article, yet it luckily happens that this pretension, like all those that regard the heart and will, is neither difficult to be made good, nor liable to the censure of vanity : quite differently from all pretensions to what is valuable in the understanding, or in any other respect of nature or fortune. " Mr. Anderson says he was told you had been some- what indispos'd since you got home ; I hope you are by this time perfectly strong and healthy, so as to continue without fear in your resolution of spending next winter at Leyden. I heartily wish I could spend it with you, but am as yet undetermin'd. Mr. Archer, besides next winter at Edinburgh, intends, I hear, to pass another with Mr. Hucheson; in my opinion he putts off his settling in business too late, if he spend as many years as he talks of in an academical way. It was always my desire to be fixed in life, as they say, as soon as I could, consistently with the attainments necessary to what I should profess. " A letter from you, whenever you are at leisure, will be extremely welcome : you will direct it to be left at Mr. Akinside's, Surgeon, in Newcastle upon Tyne. " 1 desire you to excuse this blotted scrawl ; it is past midnight, and Mr. Anderson goes away early to-morrow. I am, Sir, with the greatest esteem and sincerity, your very affectionate and obedient servant, " MAUK AlvINSDE." LIFE OF AKENSIDE. IX This letter was the prelude to a friendship memorable for the fervour and the constancy with which it was maintained on both sides, as well as for its beneficial results to the poet. At the time it was written, I apprehend that Akenside was busily occupied in the composition of the great didactic poem, over which his genius seems to have brooded even from his boyish days ; and that, though he styles himself " Surgeon," he had not commenced any regular practice in that capacity. Mr. Dyson's ''resolution of spending next winter at Leyden," in order to prosecute the study of civil law, was carried into effect. On his return to England, in 1743,1he entered himself at one of the Inns of Court (I believe, Lincoln's Inn), and, in due time, was called to the bar. The Pleasures of Imagination being now ready for the press, we may suppose that Akenside brought the precious manuscript to London, about the middle, or towards the close, of 1743. " I have heard," says Johnson, " Dodsley relate, that when the copy was offered him, the price demanded for it, which was a hundred and twenty pounds, being such as he was not inclined to give precipi- tately, he carried the work to Pope, who, having looked into it, advised him not to make a niggardly offer; for ' this was no every-day writer.'"2 In consequence of this imprimatur from Twickenham, the work was published by Dodsley in January, 1744.3 Notwithstanding its metaphysical subject, 1 As appears from a letter of Professor Alberti to hiin, dated December 1st, 1743, in the possession of his son, J. Dyson, Esq. 2 Life of Akenside. 3 Quarto, pr. 4s. : see The Daily Post for January 16th, 1744 — Mr. Bucke says it was printed by Richardson, the LIFE OF AKENSIDE. so little adapted to the taste of common readers, this splendid production was received with an ap- celebrated novelist : a letter addressed to him by Aken- side will be afterwards given, and is, I suspect, Mr. Bucke's sole authority for such an assertion. A second edition, 8vo. pr. 2s. is announced in the Gent. Mag. for May, 1744. In a copy of the first edition (now in the British Museum), presented by Akenside to Dyson, is the following MS. dedication, which probably the modesty of the latter would not allow to appear in print : " Viro conjunctissimo Jeremise Dyson, Vitse, morumque suorum duci, Rerum bonarum socio, Studiorum judici, Cujus amicitia Keque sanctius habet quicquam, Neque optat carius, Hocce opusculum (Vos, O tyrannorum impure laudes Et servilium blandimenta poetarum, Abeste procul) Dat, dicat, consecratque Marcus Akinside, xvii. Calendas Jan. A.^. c. mdccxliv." This dedication was not first printed by Mr. Bucke, as that gentleman supposes : it had previously appeared in Beloe's Anecdotes, vol. i. p. 89. The Pleasures of Imagination was published anony- mously. Johnson told Boswell that when it originally came out, Rolt (a now forgotten author) went over to Dublin, and published an edition of it in his own name ; upon the fame of which he lived for several months, being entertained at the best tables as " the ingenious Mr. Rolt ;" and that Akenside having being informed of this imposition vindicated his right by publishing the poem with its real author's name. Boswell adds in a note : " I have had enquiry made in Ireland as to this story, but do not find it recollected there. I give it on the authority of Dr. Johnson, to which may be added that of the Bio- graphical Dictionary and Biographia Dramatica, in both LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XI plause1 which at once raised the author, who had only completed his twenty-third year, to a dis- tinguished station among the poets of the day. When it first appeared, Pope was sinking under the malady which, a few months after, removed him from the poetic throne ; Swift was still alive, but in the stupor of idiotcy ; Thomson had won by The Seasons an unfading laurel, to which he was destined to add another wreath by The Castle of which it has stood many years. Mr. Malone observes, that the truth probably is, not that an edition was pub- lished with Rolt's name in the title-page, but that the poem, being then anonymous, Rolt acquiesced in its being attributed to him in conversation." — Life of Johnson, i. 342, ed. 1816. 1 Gray, however, who was not yet known to the world as a poet, passed a depreciating criticism on it in a letter to Thomas Wharton, M.D. of Old Park, near Durham. It is dated from Cambridge, April 26th, 1744: " You desire to know, it seems, what character the poem of your young friend bears here. I wonder that you ask the opinion of a nation, where those who pretend to judge do not judge at all ; and the rest (the wiser part) wait to catch the judgment of the world immediately above them ; that is, Dick's and the Rainbow Coffee Houses. Your readier way would be to ask the ladies that keep the bars in those two theatres of criticism. However, to show you that I am a judge, as well as my countrymen, I will tell you, though I have rather turned it over than read it (but no matter ; no more have they), that it seems to me above the middling ; and now and then, for a little while, rises even to the best, particularly in description. It is often obscure, and even unintelligible ; and too much infected with the Hutchinson jargon. In short, its great fault is, that it was published at least nine years too early. And so methinks in a few words, ■ a la mode du Temple,' I have pertly dispatched what perhaps may for several years have employed a very ingenious man worth fifty of myself." Mason's Memoirs of Gray, 178, ed. 1775. His still more unfavourable opinion of some of Akenside's minor poems will be afterwards cited. Xll LIFE OF AKENSlDF. of Indolence ; Young was in the fulness of fame, though the four concluding portions of the Night Thoughts were yet unpublished ; Glover enjoyed a very high reputation from Leonidas ; Johnson was known only as the author of an admired satire, London ; Dyer had put forth Gronger Hill, and The Ruins of Home, with little success, — his Fleece was yet to come ; Collins had vainly en- deavoured to attract notice by his Eclogues and Epistle to Hanmer, — his Odes being of a later date ; Shenstone had produced little, but among that little was The School-mistress ; Blair had published The Grave ; and Armstrong, who had only a disgraceful notoriety from a licentious poem,1 was soon to rival Akenside as a didactic writer. The applause which hailed the first appearance of The Pleasures of Imagination had scarcely sub- sided, when Akenside found that he had roused an adversary of formidable powers. Having adopted the opinion of Lord Shaftesbury, that ridicule is the test of truth, he had annexed to a passage in the third book of his poem a long note on the subject, in which Warburton chose to discover an offensive allusion to himself. When, therefore, that mighty dogmatist, about two months after, put forth his Remarks on Several Occasional Re- flections, in answer to Dr. Middleton, Sfc.2 he de- voted to Akenside the whole of a sneering and 1 The Economy of Love. His Art of Preserving Health was published in April, 1744 : see The Daily Post for the 1 2th of that month. 2 Published in March, 1744: see The Daily Post for the 16th of that month. LIFE OF AKENSIDE. xiii caustic Preface,1 which opens thus : " In the Pre- fatory Discourse to the first volume oftheD.pvine] L.[egation] I spoke pretty largely of the Use of Ridicule in religious subjects ; as the Abuse of it is amongst the fashionable arts of Free-thinking: for which I have been just now call'd to account, without any ceremony, by the nameless author of a poem entitled The Pleasures of Imagination. For 'tis my fortune to be still concern'd with those who either do go masked, or those who should. I am a plain man, and on my first appearance in this way, I told my name and who I belonged to. After this, if men will rudely come upon me in disguise, they can have no reason to complain, that (in my ignorance of their characters) I treat them all alike upon the same free footing they have put themselves. This gentleman, a follower of Ld. S.[haftesbury], and, as it should seem, one of those to whom that Preface was addressed ; certainly, one of those to whom I applied the words of Tully, non decef, nan datum est ; who affect wit and rail- lery on subjects not meet, and with talents un- equal; this gentleman, I say, in the 105th and 106th pages of his Poem, animadverts upon me in the following manner : Since (says he) it is beyond ail contradiction evident that ice have a natural sense or feeling of the ridiculous, and since so good a reason may be assigned to justify the supreme Being for 1 This Preface was afterwards reprinted, with some slight alterations, as a Postscript to the Dedication to the Free-thinkers in a new edition of the Divine Legation of Moses. — Both Mr. D'Israeli (Quarrels of Authors, i. 9 7 J>, and Mr. Bucke (Life of Akenside, 37), seem not to know where Warburton's attack on the poet originally appeared. Xiv LIFE OF AKENSIDE. bestowing it ; one cannot without astonishment re- flect on the conduct of those men who imagine it for the service of true religion to vilify and blacken it without distinction, and endeavour to persuade us that it is never applied but in a bad cause" Warburton then proceeds to a very minute examination of the obnoxious note ;x he insinuates that Akenside is a deist, even a favourer of atheism ; and, though he attacks his philosophy, and not his poetry, he re- peatedly terms him " our poet" in a manner truly provoking. In conclusion, he asserts that a passage in the third book of the poem is an insult to the whole body of the clergy.2 An Epistle to the Rev. Mr. Warburton, occasioned by his treatment of the author of the Pleasures of Imagination, appeared about six weeks after the publication which had called it forth.3 Though this angry letter, which displays considerable in- genuity of argument without much grace of style, is generally attributed to the friendly pen of Mr. Dyson, I am inclined to believe that the greater part of it was composed by Akenside.4 The fol- lowing quotation forms its commencement : 1 See the note on ver. 262 of the third book of The Pleasures of Imagination, 2 Ver. 109— " Others of graver mien, behold, adorned With holy ensigns," &c. 3 Octavo, pr. 6c?. Published May 1st, 1744: see The Daily Post of that date. The motto on the title is " Neque solum quid istum audire, verum etiam quid me deceat dicere, considerabo." Cic. in Verr. It consists of thirty pages. 4 In a letter to Mr. Dyson (see p. xviii. of this Memoir) Akenside desires " a copy of that answer to Warburton" to be sent to Holland. If it had been entirely the work of his loved (or rather, adored) friend, would he have mentioned it in such terms ? LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XV " Sir, u Notwithstanding the pains you have taken to dis- courage all men from entering into any controversy with you ; and notwithstanding the severe example you have just been making of one, who, as you fancied, had pre- sumed to call you to account : you must still be content to be accountable for your writings, and must once more bear the mortification of being actually called to account for them. " Tis the Preface to your late Remarks that you are now called upon to justify: in which you have thought fit to treat upon a mighty free footing (as you style it, but in the apprehension of most people, upon a very in- jurious one), the ingenious and worthy author of the poem entitled, The Pleasures of Imagination. The fa- vourable reception and applause that performance has met with, render it unnecessary, and indeed impertinent, for me to enlarge in its praise, especially as you, Sir, have not condescended to enter into a particular censure of the poem ; however, by some general hints scatter'd up and down, as well as by the affectation of perpetually styling the author our poet, you may have let us see how you stand affected towards it. Whether it be indeed that dull, trivial, useless thing you seem to represent it, I shall not dispute with you; but am content to leave, as to this point, Mr. W.'s judgment staked against the general re- putation of the poem. The point I am immediately con- cern'd with is, your unbecoming treatment of the author, which, as it is so interwoven thro' the whole course of your Preface, as to be sufficiently evident, without the allegation of particular passages ; so we shall find there are not wanting repeated instances of direct and notorious ill usage ; such usage, as tho' the provocation had been ever so just, and the imagined attack upon you ever so real, would yet have been unwarrantable, and which, therefore, can't admit of the least shadow of an excuse, when it shall appear that you had really no provocation at all. For the very fact with which you set out, and which is the foundation, I suppose, of all your indignation, is an entire mistake. You tell us, you have been just now called to account, §-c. This, I say, is an absolute mistake. And, as for my own part, I never suspected that the note you refer to had anything personal in it, so I am au- thorized to affirm, that it was not at all intended per- sonally." XVI LIFE OF AKENSIDE. To this Letter Warburton returned no answer. In the remodelled copy of his poem, Akenside re- duced into a comparatively short passage the lines which treat of Ridicule, and which were certainly the least pleasing portion of the work. He, doubt- less, writhed under Warburton' s vigorous attack, for which, as will be shown in the course of this memoir, he, long after, made a sort of requital. Though the Epistle to Warburton appears not to have been published, it was certainly printed, before Akenside went to Leyden for the purpose of obtaining the degree of Doctor of Physic. This is proved by an allusion to it in the first of the following very interesting letters1 to his beloved friend, Mr. Dyson. The erroneous statement of his biographers, that he visited Holland at an earlier period than 1744, has been already noticed. "Leyden, April 7th, N. S. 1744. " Dear Dyson, "At last I am in a condition to recollect myself suffi- ciently to write to you. Ever since I left you, I have been from hour to hour ingag'd by a succession of most trivial circumstances, and yet importunate enough to force my attention from those objects, to which it most naturally and habitually inclines. I now begin to respire, and can fancy myself at Lincoln's Inn, meeting you after a very tedious absence of eight days : and telling the little occur- rences I have met with ; a story in other respects too in- considerable to be repeated ; but which, in repeating it to my friend, acquires an importance superior to the annals of a king's posterity. "I went onboard from Harwich on Thursday morning, and got ashore at Helveotsluys just about the same time on Saturday. I was not in the least sick. I am now settled in Eoebuck's chamber, the same house with Mr. Drew and Brocklesby. This last was the only one of my 1 Now first published. LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XV11 acquaintance I found here, and I dare say if you were now to return to Ley den, you would think the acquaint- ance of those who have come hither since you went away, very, very far from compensating the loss of those whose conversation you had the happiness to injoy. There are not above ten or twelve English, Scotch, and Irish now at Leyden. " As I was in the street yesterday, Mr. Schwartz, who had been told by somebody or other that I was a friend of Mr. Dyson's, came up to me and inquir'd very affec- tionately after you. I am just come from sitting the after- noon with him ; he could hardly talk of anything but you ; yet complains that you neglect to write to him. He is uncertain whether he shall be in London this summer or not ; but says he is very well acquainted with all the streets there, he has so carefully studied them in the map. I love the good nature and simplicity of his manners, and love his company more than any body's in Leyden, for I see that whenever we are together we shall fall a talking about you immediately. " I have been with Mr. Gronovius l and the Doctor, who make an excelient contrast, both as to their manners and studies ; about the latter of these the}* are constantly rallying and joking on each other. Mr. Gronovius shew'd me his Kicander, about which he has taken vast pains. He has above six hundred emendations of the text, and scholia, but wants an unpublish'd paraphrase of the au- thor, which, it seems, is in a library at Vienna. He talks of making this little book as large as his last iElian. I wish you could get the Pindar, which I hear is probably by this time finish'd at Glasgow, in one volume, the same size and type with the Theophrastus. Mr. Brocklesby tells me of an edition of Shaftesbury in the press at Dub- lin, with new copperplates : to which a fourth volume will be added, consisting of the two epistolary pamphlets and unpublish'd letters of Ld. Molesworth to my 2 master. " I will not spend time in giving you my sentiments of Holland or Leyden, they are so intirely the same with 1 Abraham Gronovius. The Nicander, here mentioned, was never published. 2 An allusion to the Preface to Remarks cm Occasional Reflections, kc.Aw which Warburton more than once calls Shaftesbury Akenside's u Master." XV111 LIFE OF AKENSIDE. what you express'd to me. One thing struck me very strongly, the absurd inconsistence between their ceremo- nious foppishness (miscalled politeness) and their gross insensibility to the true decorum in numberless instances, especially among the women. Such is their architec- ture, their painting, their music ; such their dress, the furniture of their houses, the air of their chariots, and the countenance of their polity, that when I think of Eng- land, I cannot now help paying it the same veneration and applause which at London I thought due only to Athens, to Corinth, or to Syracuse. You, who know Hol- land, will excuse me for talking in this way, after so short a view of it as I have had ;! because you know how ob- vious these appearances are, and how great an uniformity runs through the whole constitution of the country, na- tural and moral. " Mr. Ready is well, and sends his service ; as do all your other acquaintances. You will soon see Mr. Drew, for he is a printing his Thesis, and takes London in his way home. "Be so good as to present my compliments to Mrs. Dyson, Miss Dyson, and all the rest of your friends and mine. You will know whom I mean without a list of them ; only, lest jtou should not think on them, allow me to mention Mr. Ward and Mr. Ramsay. And pray forget not to make my apology to Mr. Pickering, for I utterly forgot to call upon him at my leaving London, which has since vex'd me not a little. " Be sure you write to me immediately. Let me know how you manage about the Basilica, and what informa- tion Mr. Ramsay has given you. If you call at Dodsley's, he will give you a copy of that answer to Warburton ; I should be glad if you could send it inclos'd in your first letter, and if you could give me your opinion about Dr. Armstrong's poem.2 Write me a very long letter, and direct it to Mc-Carthy's. I think I am rather freer than I should have been if boarding : tho', heaven knows, my pleasure at noon is meerly in dining, properly so call'd. Farewell, my friend, my good genius, and above all things, believe me for ever most affectionately, most intirely, only yours, " M. Akinside." 1 This passage decidedly proves that Akenside had not previously visited Holland. 2 The Art of Preserving Health, LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XlX " Leyden, April 17th, N. S. 1744. " Dear Mr. Dyson, " I had not been above four days at Leyden before two of my Edinburgh acquaintances, Mr. Austin and Mr. Hume, came hither from their winter quarters at Ghent, to make the tour of Holland. I was glad of the oppor- tunity to go along with them, as I had no prospect of any company so desirable. At my return, I found your letter, by which I see we had been writing to each other precisely at the same time. I always was afraid you would be uneasy in waiting so long for a letter : and in- deed I should have wrote directly from Helvoetsluys, but for a mistaken supposition that the post went from Ley- den on Saturday night, and that consequently I should save no time by writing before I got to my journey's end. Would to God this may find you perfectly recover'd and in free spirits ; I dare not, I cannot suffer my imagination to conceive otherwise. The whole day after we parted, I was dreading the consequence of your being abroad in so damp a morning, and lodging in that vile inn, at a time when your health was far from being confirm'd. In every other circumstance, I need not tell you what hap- piness your letter gave me. Believe me, my dear, my honour'd friend, I look upon my connection with you as the most fortunate circumstance of my life. I never think of it without being happier and better for the reflection. I injoy, by means of it, a more animated, a more perfect relish of every social, of every natural pleasure. My own character, by means of it, is become an object of venera- tion and applause to myself. My sense of the perfection and goodness of the Supreme Being is nobler and more affecting. It is that good, that beauty with which my mind is filFd, and which serves as a sacred antidote against the influence of that moral evil which is in the world, when it would perplex and distress me. It has the force of an additional conscience, of a new principle of religion : nor do I remember one instance of moral good or evil offer'd to my choice of late, in which the idea of your mind and manners did not come in along with the essential beauty of virtue and the sanction of the divine laws to guide and determine me. It has inlarg'd my knowledge of human nature, and ascertain'd my ideas of the ceconomy of the universe. In whatever light I con- sider, with whatever principle or sensation I compare it, XX LIFE OF AKENSIDE. it still continues to receive strength from the Lest and highest, and in return confirm and inlarge them, like the sweet south, That breathes upon a bank of violets, Giving and stealing odours. I have sometimes, when in a cold or more sceptical turn of thought than is natural to my temper, hesitated whe- ther this affection might not and did not too much en- gross my mind. But in a moment I saw, and you, my friend, know and feel with what satisfaction not to be described, that it was impossible to indulge it too much, in any other sense than as it is possible to carry too far our regard for the Supreme Being ; that is, to lose sight of its natural tendency and run counter to the very spirit with which it was instituted : in other words, while we continue to cultivate our friendship, intire and extensive as its foundations now are, it cannot ingross our minds too much, or exert too general an influence on our con- duct. " Perhaps you expect some account of my travels. Indeed I cannot say more than that they confirm'd all my former ideas of the Dutch genius and taste. Minute and careful in execution T but flat and inelegant and nar- row in design. Their buildings, their gardens, their civil forms, every thing, give the same information. At Am- sterdam I saw a Dutch tragedy, which, tho' intended to be really distressful, was yet farcical beyond anything in Aristophanes, or the Rehearsal. And these farcical parts were the only things that mov'd the audience in the very least degree. And in the middle of the distress, in those boxes where people of the best figure use to sit, the glass and brandy bottle was going about among both men and women. " As for my acquaintance here, it lies chiefly, almost wholly, among the gentlemen that lodge with Mr. Van- derlas : the others, at the ordinary, have given me no reason to alter the account 3-011 had in my last. Mr. Ready, as far as I am able to judge, is a very amiable man, and much a gentleman; and young Mr. Canowan, I hope, will turn out very well in the world, especially as I see he is much less attach'd to the bigotry and nar- row spirit of the Roman Catholic religion. Mr, Schwartz spent this afternoon with me, and all salute you. I need LIFE OF AKEXSIDE. Xxi not desire you to express for me the warmest sentiments of friendship and respect to Mrs. Dyson and Miss Dy- sons, nor to remember me to all our other friends. I am within five minutes of the post, and very sorry to part so soon. Farewell, my dearest Dyson. Ever yours, " M. Akinside." " Friday Evening. " To Mr. Dyson, at Serle's Coffee-house, " Lincoln's Inn, London." " Leyden, April 21st, ST. S. 1744. a My dearest Dyson, " I have just received and read your letter, by which I find we have been a second time imploy'd in writing to each other at the same instant : from what sympathetic influence of our minds one upon the other, or what invi- sible agency of superior genii favourable to friendship, I cannot tell. But that your writing was a sort of present and immediate security for your being tolerably well, I should have been much alarm'd at the account you give of the return of your disorder. But now I hope 'tis fairly over, and that you have laid in a stock of health and good spirits for a very long time. For my own part, since I left you, I have indeed been well, in the vulgar sense of the phrase, that is to say, my appetite, my sleeps, my pulse, and the rest of that kind have been regular and sound: but the other more desirable sort of good health, that which consists in the perfect, the harmonious possession of one's own mind, in the exercise of its best facultys upon those objects which are most adapted to it by nature and habit, and, above all things, in that con- scious, that inexplicable feeling that ice are happy; this kind of health, I confess, I have not injoy'd so intire for these three weeks : nor do I expect to injoy it, till I re- turn to that situation which taught me first to conceive it. The more I see of Holland (and I imagine the case would be the same were I to travel thro' the world), the more I love and honour my native country. The man- ners of the people, the political forms, the genius of the constitution, the temper of the laws, the accidental objects of dress and behaviour one meets with in the streets, the very face of their buildings, and outward appearance of the country in general, only serve to put me in mind of England, with a greater desire of returning. In the same manner as all that variety of mix'd company I have XXII LIFE OF AKENSIDE. pass'd thro' this last year or two, only gave me a stronger sense of my happiness when I got home to you. "lam [at] present buried among medical books; col- lecting facts, and comparing opinions among the dullest of mortal men, and that, too, in their dullest capacity, that of authors. However, I hope this necessary task will grow more agreeable, when I shall be at leisure to attend to the justness of argument and the decency of ex- pression. As I spend no time so agreeably as in reading your letters, or (next to that) in conversing with you even after this imperfect manner, I could not forbear sitting down immediately to write, especially as I was so much straitened for time last post. I am very glad that people shew so much unanimity about the war against France ; and, for my own part, I have not the least doubt of the superiority of our national spirit, and consequently of our success in general ; only I am afraid that we shall want generals, and that the war will be too much carried on, on our part, by land. I can't say I was much pleased with the declaration of war (I mean the formula, not the thing), the style seem'd to me rather that of a private man clearing himself from some unbecoming imputa- tions, than that of the chief magistrate of a mighty and free people proclaiming war against the most formidable people in the world, in defence of justice, and drawn to it by the disinterested succour of an oppress'd and in- sulted ally. The speech to the parliament I could not indeed but approve : there was an expression either in it, or in the declaration against France, quite equal to the occasion ; * I appeal to the whole world for the equity and rectitude of my conduct.' It is certainly very great, and has but one impropriety (indeed, a very essential one), that the honour due to the people of Britain for the generosity and fearless love of justice they have, under such vast pressures, manifested upon this occasion, is, by this way of speaking, unavoidable in our government, attributed to one man, who has no other merit in the affair, than meerly in not imbezzling the vast sums which have been advanc'd in support of the common cause. " You would see by my last that I cannot finish my affairs here so soon as you suppos'd. But what time I lost in the beginning by going to Amsterdam, &c, I shall gain towards the end of my stay here ; so that I hope to be in London, at least in England, within a month at latest. I have long indulged myself in an LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XXlll agreeable prospect of settling at S., chiefly because of my opportunity of seeing you frequently, and next to that (if indeed it be not a consideration more important), in making such acquaintances during the summer seasons, as might put it sooner in my power to spend the remain- der of my life without interruption beside you. But since the expectation was ill founded, we must make ourselves easy, and look out in Northampton, or any other place tolerably near home. For of this one thing I am certain : never to be far from you. I would have you write as soon as you can, if it be but to tell me how long your journey to Shropshire will take you; because, if you determine to go thither, I shall take shipping from Rotterdam to Newcastle, as you will probably be gone before I can reach London even by the pacquet. At this moment, while I write this, I feel something of the pain of a second parting. " As the auctions were almost intirely over before I got hither, I have not bought many books, nor expect to buymanj^. I have, however, got a few classics, and such medical books as are most useful at present. Those that are rather for curiosity and medical erudition, I shall leave commissions for with some acquaintance or other. I find what you told me to be very true, that the old and best editions of the Greek authors are dearer here than in London. Mr. Gronovius tells me, what perhaps you do not know, that Mr. Freeman is to return to Leyden : by which I judge he has intirely dedicated himself to Greek (properly so called) and to editorial criticism (ex- cuse the phrase). I think Gronovius one of the strangest men I ever met with. " Farewell, my dear friend. I know you oft think of me, and need not be told how oft and how affectionately I remember you. " Ever and intirely yours, " Mark Akinside." " Tuesday Afternoon." " P. S. I wish you would leave off writing upon gilt paper, unless you can get sheets of it as large as this. I forgot to tell you, that Wetstein at Amsterdam shew'd me the unflnish'd Diodorus Siculus ; it is printed exactly like the last Thucydides, but how accurately I cannot tell. Forget not my compliments at Charter-house Square, nor to Mr. Harrison, Mr. Dyson, and the rest of our friends. XXIV LIFE OF AKENSIDE. Mr. Gronovius, Mr. Schwartz, Mr. Ready, and all your 's here salute you. " I have just been at Langeratu's to inquire about the Basilica, but not finding him, must refer it to another opportunity." On the 16th May, 1744,1 Akenside took his de- gree of Doctor of Physic, at Leyden, the subject of his Dissertatio Medica Inauguralis being De ortu et incremento fcetus liumani ;2 and, doubtless, as soon as he had obtained his diploma, he hastened back to England. In the collection of Odes, which he published in the following year, is an Ode On leaving Holland. He was now desirous to commence the practice of his profession ; and having heard that he had a prospect of succeeding at Northampton, and having made some necessary enquiries on the spot, in June, 1744,3 he soon after fixed himself there as a physician. It was not long, however, before he found that the chief medical business of the place was in the hands of Dr. Stonehouse, from whom it was not to be wrested by a stranger ; 4 1 See note at page xlii. of this Memoir. 2 Printed at Leyden in 1744, 4to. " In this disserta- tion the author is said to have displayed his medical sagacity by attacking some opinions of Leeuwenhoek and other writers, at that time very generally received, but which have been since discarded by the best physicians and philosophers ; and by proposing an hypothesis which is now considered as founded in truth." — Kippis's Bioy. Brit 3 From the information of Mr. Dyson, (October 25th, 1834,) who thus describes the contents of one of the poet's letters to his father : " On the 1 4th June [1744] he writes from Northampton to report the result of his enquiries in relation to the expediency of his settling there, which was such as induced him to do so." 4 A correspondent (who signs himself Indagator) in the LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XXV and having maintained a fruitless contest with that gentleman, and perhaps disliking Northampton on account of its distance from the capital, he quitted it, after a stay of about eighteen months, and re- moved to Hampstead. " The writer of this article," says Kippis, in a note on our author's Life,1 " who then resided at Northampton for education, well remembers that Dr. Doddridge and Dr. Akenside Gent. Mag. for October, 1793 (lxiii. 885), writes thus: " The fact, Mr. Urban, is, that this contest for the physical business at Northampton, though unsuccessful on the part of Akenside, had for some time been supported by him with extraordinary violence. I am warranted, by manu- scripts in my possession, when I say, that not only a fair and open struggle of medical hostilities, but every art and every exertion, personal abuse and private insinuation, had been used to usurp Dr. Stonehouse's professional emoluments, and oust him from his established settle- ment. Yet, on Akenside's removal from that place to Hampstead, the recommendatory letter, a copy of which I send you, was generously written in his favour by his worthy rival, as an introduction for him to a gentleman of consequence in the neighbourhood of his new abode." " Dear Sir, " The gentleman who presents you with this is Dr. Aken- side, a brother physician, whose merit, as a man of refined sense and elegance of taste, is too well known by his wri- tings (The Pleasures of the Imagination, &c.) to need any other testimonial ; and I dare say, from what you already know of them, you will naturally conclude, without any praise of mine, that such a man must be proportionably distinguished in his own peculiar profession. " I take this opportunity of introducing him to the honour of your acquaintance ; and make no doubt you will receive him as a gentleman, whom for his character and abilities I much esteem, and whose near neighbour- hood, in any place where there had been room for us both, I should have regarded as an addition to my happiness. I am," &c. See, too, Gent, Mag. for January, 1794, (lxiv. 12.) 1 Biog. Brit. XXVI LIFE OF AKENSIDE. carried on an amicable debate concerning the opi- nions of the ancient philosophers with regard to a future state of rewards and punishments ; in which Dr. Akenside supported the firm belief of Cicero in particular, in this great article of na- tural religion." According to Johnson, who hear- tily disliked his political creed, and never loses an opportunity of stigmatising it, Akenside "deafened the place with clamours for liberty."1 During his stay at Northampton (in 1744), he produced his very powerful satire, An JEpistle to Curio,2 — i. e. to the Eight Hon. William Pulteney, who, having been long the strenuous supporter of the people's cause, in opposition to the measures of government, had suddenly deserted his party, and become an object of popular execration, for the sake of an empty title, the Earldom of Bath. This justly-admired piece he afterwards injudi- ciously altered into an ode. The following letter, undoubtedly genuine, and never before printed in England, is given from a facsimile of the original in a American edition of our author's works:3 " Northampton, May 21st, 1745. " Dear Sib, " When I look on the date of your letter, I am very glad that I have any excuse, however disagreeable, for not answering it long ere this. About a month ago, when I w^as thinking every post to write to you, I was thrown 1 Life of Akenside. 2 Published by Dodsley, 4to. pr. Is. : See List of Books for Xovember, 1744, in the Gent. Mag. On the title-page is this motto : " Neque tarn ulciscendi causa dixi, quam ut et in prcesens sceleratos cives timore ah impugnanda patria detinerem; et in poster um documentum statuerem, neqids talem amentiam vellet imitari" — TuLL. 3 Printed at Xewr Brunswick, 1808, 2 vols. 8vo. LIFE OF AKENSIDE. XXV11 from my horse with a very great hazard of my life, and confined a good while afterwards from either writing or reading. But, thank heaven, for these ten days I have been perfectly well. You are very good-natured about the verses. If they gave you any pleasure, I shall con- clude my principal end in publishing them to be fairly answer'd. And that you look upon your reading them in manuscript, and this way of seeing them in print, as an instance of real friendship, gives me great satisfaction. As for public influence, if they have any, I hope it will be a good one. But my expectations of that kind are not near so sanguine as they once were. Indeed human nature in its genuine habit and constitution is adapted to very powerful impressions from this sort of entertain- ment : but in the present state of manners and opinions, it is almost solely on the retir'd and studious of nature, that this effect can be looked for : for hardly any besides these have been able to preserve the genuine habit of the mind in any tolerable degree. I am, dear Sir, your most obedient and most humble servant, « To M. Wilkes, Jdn. " M. Akinside." St. John's-street, London." Here probably he alludes to his Odes on Several Subjects, which had been published more than two1 1 Dodsley, 4to. pr. Is. 6^. See List of Books for March, 1745, in the Gent Mag. This tract consists of fifty- four pages, and has the following motto from Pindar : Xpvebv sv^ovrai, 7rediov o" srepoi airepavTOV kyuj fr aarolg adujp, Kal xOovl yvla Ka\v\pai- jjl\ alvkujv alvrjrd, juo/x- His hateful presence : but permit my tongue One glad request, and if my deeds may find Thy awful eye propitious, Oh ! restore The rosy featured maid ; again to cheer This lonely seat, and bless me with her smiles." He spoke; when, instant, through the sable glooms With which that furious presence had involved The ambient air, a flood of radiance came Swift as the lightning flash ; the melting clouds Flew diverse, and, amid the blue serene, 6io Euphrosyne appeared. With sprightly step The nymph alighted on the irriguous lawn, And to her wondering audience thus began : " Lo ! I am here to answer to your vows ; And be the meeting fortunate ! I come "With joyful tidings ; we shall part no more — Hark ! how the gentle echo from her cell Talks through the cliffs, and murmuring o'er the stream Repeats the accent; we shall part no more. — O my delightful friends ! well pleased, on high, 650 The Father has beheld you, while the might Of that stern foe with bitter trial proved Your equal doings : then for ever spake The high decree ; that thou, celestial maid ! Howe'er that grisly phantom on thy steps 42 THE PLEASURES OF May sometimes dare intrude, yet never more Shalt thou, descending to the abode of man, Alone endure the rancour of his arm, Or leave thy loved Euphrosyne behind." She ended ; and the whole romantic scene 660 Immediate vanished ; rocks, and woods, and rills, The mantling tent, and each mysterious form Flew like the pictures of a morning dream, When sunshine fills the bed. Awhile I stood Perplexed and giddy ; till the radiant power Who bade the visionary landscape rise, As up to him I turned, with gentlest looks Preventing my enquiry, thus began : " There let thy soul acknowledge its complaint ; Plow blind, how impious ! There behold the ways Of Heaven's eternal destiny to man, 671 For ever just, benevolent, and wise : That Virtue's awful steps, howe'er pursued By vexing fortune and intrusive pain, Should never be divided from her chaste, Her fair attendant, Pleasure. Need I urge Thy tardy thought through all the various round Of this existence, that thy softening soul At length may learn what energy the hand Of virtue mingles in the bitter tide (%o Of passion, swelling with distress and pain, To mitigate the sharp with gracious drops Of cordial pleasure ? Ask the faithful youth. Why the cold urn of her whom long he loved So often fills his arms ; so often draws His lonely footsteps, at the silent hour, To pay the mournful tribute of his tears ? Oh ! he will tell thee, that the wealth of worlds Should ne'er seduce his bosom to forego 689 That sacred hour, when, stealing from the noise Of care and envy, sweet remembrance soothes IMAGINATION. BOOK II. 43 With virtue's kindest looks his aching breast, And turns his tears to rapture. — Ask the crowd Which flies impatient from the village walk To climb the neighbouring cliffs, when, far below. The cruel winds have hurled upon the coast Some helpless bark ; while sacred Pity melts ; The general eye, or Terror's icy hand Smites their distorted limbs and horrent hair ; While every mother closer to her breast 700 Catches her child, and, pointing where the wraves Foam through the shattered vessel, shrieks aloud As one poor wretch that spreads his piteous arms For succour, swallowed by the roaring surge, As now another, dashed against the rock, Drops lifeless down : Oh ! deemest thou indeed No kind endearment here by Nature given To mutual terror and compassion's tears ? No sweetly melting softness which attracts, O'er all that edge of pain, the social powers 710 To this their proper action and their end ? — Ask thy own heart ; when, at the midnight hour, Slow through that studious gloom, thy pausing eye, Led by the glimmering taper, moves around The sacred Volumes of the dead, the songs Of Grecian bards, and records wrote by Fame For Grecian heroes, where the present power Of heaven and earth surveys the immortal page, Even as a father blessing, while he reads The praises of his son. If then thy soul, 720 Spurning the yoke of these inglorious days, Mix in their deeds, and kindle with their flame ; Say, when the prospect blackens on thy view, When, rooted from the base, heroic states Mourn in the dust, and tremble at the frown Of curst ambition ; when the pious band12 Of youths who fought for freedom and their sires 44 THE PLEASURES OF Lie side by side in gore ; when ruffian pride Usurps the throne of Justice, turns the pomp Of public power, the majesty of rule, 730 The sword, the laurel," and the purple robe, To slavish empty pageants, to adorn A tyrant's walk, and glitter in the eyes Of such as bow the knee ; when honoured urns Of patriots and of chiefs, the awful bust And storied arch, to glut the coward rage Of regal envy, strew the public way With hallowed ruins ; when the Muse's haunt, The marble porch where Wisdom wont to talk With Socrates or Tully, hears no more, 740 Save the hoarse jargon of contentious monks, Or female Superstition's midnight prayer ; When ruthless Rapine from the hand of Time Tears the destroying scythe, with surer blow To sweep the works of glory from their base ; Till Desolation o'er the grass-grown street Expands his raven wings, and up the wall, Where senates once the price of monarchs doomed, Hisses the gliding snake through hoary weeds 749 That clasp the mouldering column ; thus defaced, Thus widely mournful when the prospect thrills Thy beating bosom, when the patriot's tear Starts from thine eye, and thy extended arm In fancy hurls the thunderbolt of Jove To fire the impious wreath on Philip's13 brow, Or dash Octavius from the trophied car ; Say, does thy secret soul repine to taste The big distress ? Or wouldest thou then exchange Those heart-ennobling sorrows for the lot Of him who sits amid the gaudy herd 760 Of mute barbarians, bending to his nod, And bears aloft his gold-invested front, And says within himself, ' I am a king, IMAGINATION. BOOK II. 45 And wherefore should the clamorous voice of woe Intrude upon mine ear ? ' — The baleful dregs Of these late ages, this inglorious draught Of servitude and folly, have not yet, Blest be the eternal Ruler of the world, Denied to such a depth of sordid shame The native honours of the human soul, ?;o Xor so effaced the image of its Sire." 46 THE PLEASURES OF BOOK III. THE ARGUMENT. Pleasure in observing the tempers and manners of men, even where vicious or absurd. The origin of Vice $ from false representations of the fancy, producing false opinions concerning good and evil. Inquiry into ridicule. The general sources of ridicule in the minds and characters of men, enumerated. Final cause of the sense of ridicule. The resemblance of certain aspects of inanimate things to the sensations and pro- perties of the mind. The operations of the mind in the production of the works of Imagination, described. The secondary pleasure from Imitation. The bene- volent order of the world illustrated in the arbitrary connection of these pleasures with the objects which excite them. The nature and conduct of taste. Con- cluding with an account of the natural and moral advantages resulting from a sensible and well formed imagination. ?HAT wonder therefore, since the en- dearing ties Of passion link the universal kind Of man so close, what wonder if to search This common nature through the various change Of sex, and age, and fortune, and the frame Of each peculiar, draw the busy mind With unresisted charms ! The spacious west, IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 47 And all the teeming regions of the south, Hold not a quarry, to the curious night Gf Knowledge, half so tempting or so fair, 10 As man to man. Nor only where the smiles Of Love invite ; nor only where the applause Of cordial Honour turns the attentive eye On Virtue's graceful deeds. For since the course Of things external acts in different ways On human apprehensions, as the hand Of Nature tempered to a different frame Peculiar minds ; so, haply, where the powers Of Fancy neither lessen nor enlarge The images of things, but paint in all 20 Their genuine hues, the features which they wore In Nature ;l there Opinion will be true, And Action right. For Action treads the path In which Opinion says he follows good, Or flies from evil ; and Opinion gives Report of good or evil, as the scene Was drawn by Fancy, lovely or deformed : Thus her report can never there be true, Where Fancy cheats the intellectual eye, With glaring colours and distorted lines. 30 Is there a man, who, at the sound of death, Sees ghastly shapes of terror conjured up, [groans, And black before him; nought but death-bed And fearful prayers, and plunging from the brink Of light and being, down the gloomy air ; An unknown depth ? Alas ! in such a mind, If no bright forms of excellence attend The image of his country ; nor the pomp Of sacred senates, nor the guardian voice Of Justice on her throne, nor aught that wakes 40 The conscious bosom with a patriot's flame ; Will not Opinion tell him, that to die, Or stand the hazard, is a greater ill 48 THE PLEASURES OF Than to betray his country ? And, in act, Will he not choose to be a wretch and live ? Here vice begins then. From the enchanting cup Which Fancy holds to all, the unwary thirst Of youth oft swallows a Circsean draught, That sheds a baleful tincture o'er the eye Of Reason, till no longer he discerns, 50 And only guides to err. Then revel forth A furious band that spurn him from the throne ; And all is uproar. Thus ambition grasps The empire of the soul : thus pale Revenge Unsheaths her murderous dagger ; and the hands Of Lust and Rapine, with unholy arts, Watch to o'erturn the barrier of the laws That keeps them from their prey : thus all the plagues The wicked bear, or, o'er the trembling scene, The tragic Muse discloses, under shapes 60 Of honour, safety, pleasure, ease, or pomp, Stole first into the mind. Yet not by all Those lying forms which Fancy in the brain Engenders, are the kindling passions driven To guilty deeds ; nor Reason bound in chains, That Vice alone may lord it : oft, adorned With solemn pageants, Folly mounts the throne And plays her idiot antics, like a queen. A thousand garbs she wears ; a thousand ways She wheels her giddy empire. — Lo ! thus far, 70 With bold adventure, to the Mantuan lyre I sing of Nature's charms, and touch, well pleased, A stricter note : now haply must my song Unbend her serious measure, and reveal, In lighter strains, how Folly's awkward arts Excite impetuous Laughter's gay rebuke ;2 The sportive province of the comic Muse. See ! in what crowds the uncouth forms advance : IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 49 Each would outstrip the other, each prevent Our careful search, and offer to your gaze, so Unasked, his motley features. Wait awhile, My curious friends ! and let us first arrange In proper orders your promiscuous throng. Behold the foremost band ;3 of slender thought And easy faith, whom flattering Fancy soothes, With lying spectres, in themselves to view Illustrious forms of excellence and good, That scorn the mansion. With exulting hearts They spread their spurious treasures to the sun, And bid the world admire. But chief the glance Of wishful Envy draws their joy-bright eyes, 91 And lifts with self-applause each lordly brow. In number boundless as the blooms of Spring, Behold their glaring idols — empty shades By Fancy gilded o'er, and then set up For adoration. Some, in Learning's garb, With formal band, and sable-cinctured gown, And rags of mouldy volumes. Some, elate With martial splendour, steely pikes and swords Of costly frame, and gay Phoenician robes 100 Inwrought with flowering gold, assume the port Of stately Valour : listening by his side There stands a female form ; to her, with looks Of earnest import, pregnant with amaze, He talks of deadly deeds, of breaches, storms, And sulphurous mines, and ambush ; then at once Breaks off, and smiles to see her look so pale, And asks some wondering question of her fears. Others of graver mien ; behold, adorned With holy ensigns, how sublime they move, 110 And, bending oft their sanctimonious eyes, Take homage of the simple-minded throng — Ambassadors of Heaven ! Nor much unlike Is he whose visage, in the lazy mist 50 THE PLEASURES OF That mantles every feature, hides a brood Of politic conceits ; of whispers, nods, And hints deep-omened with unwieldy schemes, And dark portents of state. Ten thousand more, Prodigious habits and tumultuous tongues, Pour dauntless in, and swell the boastful band. 120 Then comes the second order ;4 all who seek The debt of praise, where watchful Unbelief Darts through the thin pretence her squinting eye On some retired appearance, which belies The boasted virtue, or annuls the applause That justice else would pay. Here, side by side, I see two leaders of the solemn train Approaching : one, a female old and gray, With eyes demure and wrinkle -furrowed brow, Pale as the cheeks of death ; yet still she stuns The sickening audience with a nauseous tale : m How many youths her myrtle chains have worn ! Plow many virgins at her triumphs pined ! Yet how resolved she guards her cautious heart : Such is her terror at the risks of love, And man's seducing tongue ! The other seems A bearded sage, ungentle in his mien, And sordid all his habit ; peevish Want Grins at his heels, while down the gazing throng He stalks, resounding, in magnific praise, ho The vanity of riches, the contempt Of pomp and power. Be prudent in your zeal, Ye grave associates ! let the silent grace Of her who blushes at the fond regard Her charms inspire, more eloquent, unfold The praise of spotless honour ; let the man Whose eye regards not his illustrious pomp And ample store, but as indulgent streams To cheer the barren soil and spread the fruits Of joy, let him, by juster measure, fix 150 IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 51 The price of riches and the end of power. Another tribe succeeds ;5 deluded long By Fancy's dazzling optics, these behold The images of some peculiar things With brighter hues resplendent, and portrayed With features nobler far than e'er adorned Their genuine objects. Hence the fevered heart Pants with delirious hope for tinsel charms ; Hence, oft obtrusive on the eye of scorn, Untimely zeal her witless pride betrays ; 160 And serious manhood, from the towering aim Of wisdom, stoops to emulate the boast Of childish toil. Behold yon mystic form, Bedecked with feathers, insects, weeds, and shells! "Not with intenser view the Samian sage Bent his fixed eye on heaven's eternal fires, When first the order of that radiant scene Swelled his exulting thought, than this surveys A muckworm's entrails or a spider's fang. JSText him a youth, with flowers and myrtles crowned, 170 Attends that virgin form, and, blushing, kneels, With fondest gesture and a suppliant's tongue, To win her coy regard : adieu, for him, The dull engagements of the bustling world ! Adieu the sick impertinence of praise, And hope, and action ! for with her alone, By streams and shades, to steal the sighing hours, Is all he asks, and all that fate can give ! Thee too, facetious Momion,6 wandering here, Thee, dreaded censor ! oft have I beheld 180 Bewildered unawares: alas ! too long Flushed with thy comic triumphs and the spoils Of sly derision ; till, on every side Hurling thy random bolts, offended Truth Assigned thee here thy station, with the slaves 52 THE PLEASURES OF Of Folly. Thy once formidable name Shall grace her humble records, and be heard In scoffs and mockery, bandied from the lips Of all the vengeful brotherhood around, So oft the patient victims of thy scorn. 190 But now, ye gay !7 to whom indulgent fate, Of all the Muse's empire hath assigned The fields of folly, hither each advance Your sickles ; here the teeming soil affords Its richest growth. A favourite brood appears, In whom the demon, with a mother's joy, Views all her charms reflected, all her cares At full repaid. Ye most illustrious band ! Who, scorning Reason's tame, pedantic rules, And Order's vulgar bondage, never meant 200 For souls sublime as yours, with generous zeal Pay Yice the reverence Virtue long usurped, And yield Deformity the fond applause Which Beauty wont to claim ; forgive my song. That for the blushing diffidence of youth, It shuns the unequal province of your praise. Thus far triumphant in the pleasing guile Of bland Imagination, Folly's train Have dared our search :8 but now a dastard kind Advance, reluctant, and with faltering feet 210 Shrink from the gazer's eye ; — enfeebled hearts Whom Fancy chills with visionary fears, Or bends to servile tameness with conceits Of shame, of evil, or of base defect, Fantastic and delusive. Here the slave, Who droops abashed when sullen Pomp surveys His humbler habit ; here the trembling wretch, Unnerved, and froze with Terror's icy bolts, Spent in weak wailings, drowned in shameful tears, At every dream of danger ; here, subdued 220 By frontless laughter and the hardy scorn IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 53 Of old, unfeeling vice, the abject soul, Who, blushing, half resigns the candid praise Of Temperance and Honour ; half disowns A freeman's hatred of tyrannic pride, And hears, with sickly smiles, the venal mouth, With foulest license, mock the patriot's name. Last of the motley bands on whom the power Of gay Derision bends her hostile aim,9 Is that where shameful Ignorance presides. 230 Beneath her sordid banners, lo ! they march Like blind and lame. Whate'er their doubtful hands Attempt, Confusion straight appears behind, And troubles all the work. Thro' many a maze, Perplexed, they struggle, changing every path, O'erturning every purpose ; then, at last, Sit down dismayed, and leave the entangled scene For Scorn to sport with. Such then is the abode Of Folly in the mind, and such the shapes In which she governs her obsequious train. 240 Through every scene of ridicule in things To lead the tenor of my devious lay ; Through every swift occasion which the hand Of Laughter points at, when the mirthful sting Distends her sallying nerves and chokes her tongue ; What were it but to count each crystal drop Which Morning's dewy fingers on the blooms Of May distil ? Suffice it to have said, Where'er the power of Ridicule displays 249 Her quaint-eyed visage, some incongruous form, Some stubborn dissonance of things combined, Strikes on the quick observer : whether Pomp, Or Praise, or Beauty, mix their partial claim Where sordid fashions, where ignoble deeds, Where foul Deformity, are wont to dwell ; 54 THE PLEASURES OF Or whether these, with violation loathed, Invade resplendent Pomp's imperious mien, The charms of Beauty, or the boasts of Praise.10 Ask we for what fair end the Almighty Sire In mortal bosoms wakes this gay contempt, HE word musical is here taken in its original and most extensive import ; com- prehending as well the pleasures we re- ceive from the beauty or magnificence of natural objects, as those which arise from poetry, painting, music, or any other of the elegant or imagin- ative arts. In which sense it has been already used in our language by writers of unquestionable autho- rity. Page 7, ver. 45. 2 Lucret. lib. ii. 921. Nee me animi fallit quam sint obscura, sed acri Percussit thyrso laudis spes magna meum cor, Et simul incussit suavem mi in pectus amorem Musarum ; quo nunc instinctus mente vigenti Avia Pieridum peragro loca, nuilius ante Trita solo : juvat integros accedere fonteis, Atque haurire : juvatque novos discerpcre flores ; Insignem meo capiti petere inde coronam, Unde prius nulli velar int tempora Musae. Page 8, ver. 109. 3 The statue of Memnon, so famous in antiquity, stood in the temple of Serapis at Thebes, one of the great cities of old Egypt. It was of a very hard, iron-like stone, and, according to Juvenal, held in its hand a lyre, which, being touched by the sunbeams, emitted a distinct and agreeable sound. Tacitus mentions it as one of the principal curiosities which Germanicus took notice of in his journey through Egypt ; and Strabo affirms that he, with many others, heard it. 66 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF Page 10, ver. 152. 4 In apologizing for the fre- quent negligences of the sublimest authors of Greece, " Those god-like geniuses," says Longinus, " were well assured that Nature had not intended man for a low-spirited or ignoble being ; but bringing us into life and the midst of this wide universe, as before a multi- tude assembled at some heroic solemnity, that we might be spectators of all her magnificence, and candi- dates high in emulation for the prize of glory 5 she has therefore implanted in our souls an inextinguishable love of every thing great and exalted, of every thing which appears divine beyond our comprehension. Whence it comes to pass, that even the whole world is not an object sufficient for the depth and rapidity of human imagination, wThich often sallies forth beyond the limits of all that surrounds us. Let any man cast his eye through the whole circle of our existence, and consider how especially it abounds in excellent and grand objects, he will soon acknowledge for wrhat enjoyments and pursuits we were destined. Thus by the very propensity of nature wre are led to admire, not little springs or shallow rivulets, however clear and delicious, but the Nile, the Rhine, the Danube, and, much more than all, the Ocean, &c," Dionys. Longin. de Sublim. § 24. Page 11, ver. 202. 3 " Ne se peut-il point qu'il y a un grand espace au dela de la region des etoiles ? Que ce soit le ciel empyree, 011 non, to uj ours cet espace immense, qui environne toute cette region, pourra etre rempli de bonheur et de gloire. II pourra etre congu comme Pocean, ou se rendent les fleuves de toutes les creatures bien-heureuses, quand elles seront venues a leur perfection dans le systeme des etoiles." Leibnitz dans le Thtodicee part i. § 19. Page 11, ver. 204. 6 It was a notion of the great Mr. Huygens, that there may be fixed stars at such a distance from our solar system, as that their light should not have had time to reach us, even from the creation of the world to this day. Page 12, ver. 235. 7 It is here said, that in conse- IMAGINATION. BOOK I. 67 quence of the love of novelty, objects which at first were highly delightful to the mind, lose that effect by repeated attention to them. But the instance of habit is opposed to this observation ; for there, objects at first distasteful are in time rendered entirely agreeable by repeated attention. The difficulty in this case will be removed, if we consider, that, when objects at first agreeable, lose that influence by frequently recurring, the mind is wholly passive, and the perception involuntary ; but habit, on the other hand, generally supposes choice and activity accompanying it : so that the pleasure arises here not from the object, but from the mind's conscious deter- mination of its own activity ; and, consequently, in- creases in proportion to the frequency of that deter- mination. It will still be urged, perhaps, that a familiarity with disagreeable objects renders them at length acceptable, even when there is no room for the mind to resolve or act at all. In this case, the appearance must be accounted for one of these ways. The pleasure from habit may be merely negative. The object at first gave uneasiness : this uneasiness gradually wears off as the object grows familiar : and the mind, finding it at last entirely removed, reckons its situation really pleasurable, compared with what it had experienced before. The dislike conceived of the object at first, might be owing to prejudice or want of attention. Consequently the mind being necessitated to review it often, may at length perceive its own mistake, and be reconciled to what it had looked upon with aversion. In which case, a sort of instinctive justice naturally leads it to make amends for the injury, by running toward the other extreme of fondness and attachment. Or lastly, though the object itself should always continue disagreeable, yet circumstances of pleasure or good fortune may occur along with it. Thus an association may arise in the mind, and the object never be remembered without those pleasing circumstances 68 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF attending it ; by which means the disagreeable impres- sion which it at first occasioned will in time be quite obliterated. Page 12, ver. 240. 8 These two ideas are oft con- founded 5 though it is evident the mere novelty of an object makes it agreeable, even where the mind is not affected with the least degree of wonder : whereas wonder indeed always implies novelty, being never excited by common or well-known appearances. But the pleasure in both cases is explicable from the same final cause — the acquisition of knowledge and enlarge- ment of our views of nature : on this account, it is natural to treat of them together. Page 13, ver. 288. 9 By these islands, which were also called the Fortunate, the ancients are now generally supposed to have meant the Canaries. They were celebrated by the poets for the mildness and fertility of the climate ; for the gardens of the daughters of Hesperus, the brother of Atlas ; and the dragon which constantly watched their golden fruit, till it was slain by the Tyrian Hercules. Page 14, ver. 296. l0 Daphne, the daughter of Peneus, transformed into a laurel. Page 16, ver. 374. n " Do you imagine," says Socrates to Aristippus, i( that what is good is not also beautiful ? Have you not observed that these appear- ances always coincide ? Virtue, for instance, in the same respect as to which we call it good, is ever acknowledged to be beautiful also. In the characters of men we always* join the twro denominations together. The beauty of human bodies corresponds, in like man- ner, with that economy of parts which constitutes them good ; and in every circumstance of life, the same object is constantly accounted both beautiful and good, inasmuch as it answers the purposes for which it was designed." Xen. Mem. Socrat. I. Hi. c. 8. This excellent observation has been illustrated and * This the Athenians did in a peculiar manner, by the words Ka\oicaya6bg and KaXoKayaOia, IMAGINATION. BOOK I. 69 extended by the noble restorer of ancient philosophy ; see the Characteristics , vol. ii. pp. 339 and 422, and vol. Hi. p. 181. And his most ingenious disciple has particularly shown, that it holds in the general laws of nature, in the works of art, and the conduct of the sciences. " Inquiry into the Original of our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue" Treat, i. § 8. As to the connection between beauty and truth, there are two opinions con- cerning it. Some philosophers assert an independent and invariable law in nature, in consequence of which all rational beings must alike perceive beauty in some certain proportions, and deformity in the contrary. And this necessity being supposed the same with that which commands the assent or dissent of the under- standing, it follows of course that beauty is founded on the universal and unchangeable law of truth. But others there are, who believe beauty to be merely a relative and arbitrary thing ; that indeed it was a benevolent design in nature to annex so de- lightful a sensation to those objects which are best and most perfect in themselves, that so we might be engaged to the choice of them at once and without staying to infer their usefulness from their structure and effects ; but that it is not impossible, in a physical sense, that two beings, of equal capacities for truth, should per- ceive, one of them beauty, and the other deformity, in the same relations. And upon this supposition, by that truth which is always connected with beauty, nothing more can. be meant than the conformity of any object to those proportions upon which, after careful examination, the beauty of that species is found to depend. Polycletus, for instance, a famous ancient sculptor of Sicyon, from an accurate mensuration of the several parts of the most perfect human bodies, deduced a canon or system of proportions, which was the rule of all succeeding artists. Suppose a statue modelled according to this canon : a man of mere natural taste, upon looking at it, without entering into its proportions, confesses and admires its beauty ; whereas a professor of the art applies his measures to the head, the neck, or 70 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF the hand, and, without attending to its beauty, pro* nounces the workmanship to be just and true. Page 19, ver. 493. 12 Cicero himself describes this fact — " Csesare interfecto — statim cruentum alte ex- tollens M. Brutus pugionem, Ciceronem nominatim exclamavit, atque ei recuperatam libertatem est gratu- latus." Cic. Philipp. ii. 12. Page 21, ver. 550. 13 According to the opinion of those who assert moral obligation to be founded on an immutable and universal law ; and that pathetic feeling which is usually called the moral sense, to be determined by the peculiar temper of the imagination and the earliest associations of ideas. Page 22, ver. 591. u The school of Aristotle. Page 22, ver. 592. 15 The school of Plato. Page 22, ver. 594. 13 One of the rivers on which Athens was situated. Plato, in some of his finest dialogues, lays the scene of the conversation with Socrates on its banks. NOTES ON BOOK II. Page 24, Ver. 19. l About the age of Hugh Capet, founder of the third race of French kings, the poets of Provence were in high reputation ; a sort of strolling- bards or rhapsodists, who went about the courts of princes and noblemen, entertaining them at festivals with music and poetry. They attempted both the epic, ode, and satire ; and abounded in a wild fantastic vein of fable, partly allegorical, and partly founded on tra- ditionary legends of the Saracen wars. These were the rudiments of Italian poetry. But their taste and composition must have been extremely barbarous, as we may judge by those who followed the turn of their fable in much politer times ; such as Boiardo, Bernardo, Tasso, Ariosto, &c. Page 24, ver. 21. 2 The famous retreat of Francesco Petrarcha, the father of Italian poetry, and his mistress Laura, a lady of Avignon. IMAGINATION. BOOK II. 7i Page 24, ver. 22. 3 The river which runs by Flo- rence, the birth-place of Dante and Boccaccio. Page 24, ver. 23. 4 Or Naples, the birth-place of Sannazaro. The great Torquato Tasso was born at Sorrento, in the kingdom of Naples. Page 24, ver. 24. 3 This relates to the cruel wars among the republics of Italy, and abominable politics of its little princes, about the fifteenth century. These, at last, in conjunction with the papal power, entirely extinguished the spirit of liberty in that country, and established that abuse of the fine arts which has been since propagated over all Europe. Page 24, ver, 31. 6 Nor were they only losers by the separation. For philosophy itself, to use the words of a noble philosopher, " being thus severed from the sprightly arts and sciences, must consequently grow dronish, insipid, pedantic, useless, and directly opposite to the real knowledge and practice of the world. " Insomuch that " a gentleman," says another excellent writer, " cannot easily bring himself to like so austere and ungainly a form : so greatly is it changed from what was once the delight of the finest gentlemen of antiquity, and their recreation after the hurry of public affairs ! " From this condition it cannot be recovered but by uniting it once more with the works of imagination ; and we have had the pleasure of ob- serving a very great progress made towards their union in England, within these few years. It is hardly possible to conceive them at a greater distance from each other than at the Revolution, when Locke stood at the head of one party, and Dryden of the other. But the general spirit of liberty, which has ever since been growing, naturally invited our men of wit and genius to improve that influence which the arts of persuasion gave them with the people, by applying them to subjects of importance to society. Thus poetry and eloquence became considerable ; and phi- losophy is now of course obliged to borrow of their embellishments, in order even to gain audience with the public. 72 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF Page 27, ver. 158. 7 This very mysterious kind of pleasure, which is often found in the exercise of passions generally counted painful, has been taken notice of by several authors. Lucretius resolves it into self-love : Suave mari magno, &c. lib, ii. 1. As if a man was never pleased in being moved at the distress of a tragedy, without a cool reflection that though these fictitious personages were so unhappy, yet he himself was perfectly at ease and in safety. The ingenious author of the " Reflections Critiques sur la Poesie et sur la Peineture" accounts for it by the ge- neral delight which the mind takes in its own activity, and the abhorrence it feels of an indolent and inatten- tive state : and this, joined with the moral applause of its own temper, which attends these emotions when natural and just, is certainly the true foundation of the pleasure, which, as it is the origin and basis of tragedy and epic, deserved a very particular consideration in this poem. Page 32, ver. 306. 8 The account of the economy of providence here introduced, as the most proper to calm and satisfy the mind when under the compunction of private evils, seems to have come originally from the Pythagorean school : but of all the ancient philosophers, Plato has most largely insisted upon it, has established it with all the strength of his capacious understanding, and ennobled it with all the magnificence of his divine imagination. He has one passage so full and clear on this head, that I am persuaded the reader will be pleased to see it here, though somewhat long. Addressing himself to such as are not satisfied concerning Divine Providence : " The Being who presides over the whole," says he, " has disposed and complicated all things for the happiness and virtue of the whole, every part of which, according to the extent of its influence, does and suffers what is fit and proper. One of these parts is yours, O unhappy man ! which, though in itself most inconsiderable and minute, yet, being connected with the universe, ever seeks to co-operate with that supreme order. You, in the mean time, are ignorant of the very IMAGINATION. BOOK II. 73 end for which all particular natures are brought into existence, — that the all-comprehending nature of the whole may be perfect and happy ; existing, as it does, not for your sake, but the cause and reason of your existence, which, as in the symmetry of every artificial work, must of necessity concur with the general design of the artist, and be subservient to the whole of which it is a part. Your complaint therefore is ignorant and groundless ; since, according to the various energy of creation, and the common laws of nature, there is a con- stant provision of that which is best, at the same time, for you and for the whole. For the governing intelligence clearly beholding all the actions of animated and self- moving creatures, and that mixture of good and evil which diversifies them, considered first of all by what disposition of things, and by what situation of each individual in the general system, vice might be de- pressed and subdued, and virtue made secure of victory and happiness, with the greatest facility and in the highest degree possible. In this manner he ordered, through the entire circle of being, the internal consti- tution of every mind ; where should be its station in the universal fabric, and through what variety of circum- stances it should proceed, in the whole tenor of its existence. " He goes on in his sublime manner to assert a future state of retribution, " as well for those who, by the exercise of good dispositions, being har- monized and assimilated into the divine virtue, are con- sequently removed to a place of unblemished sanctity and happiness ; as of those who by the most flagitious arts have risen from contemptible beginnings to the greatest affluence and power, and whom therefore you look upon as unanswerable instances of negligence in the gods, because you are ignorant of the purposes to which they are subservient, and in what manner they contribute to that supreme intention of good to the whole." Plato de Leg. x. 16. This theory has been delivered of late, especially abroad, in a manner which subverts the freedom of human actions ; whereas Plato appears very careful to 74 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF preserve it, and has been, in that respect, imitated by the best of his followers. Page 32, ver. 322. 9 See the Meditations of Antoninus and the Characteristics, passim. Page 32, ver. 335. 10 This opinion is so old, that TimaBus Locrus calls the Supreme Being h]}xispybQ rS (SsXtiovoq — the artificer of that which is best ; and re- presents him as resolving in the beginning to produce the most excellent work, and as copying the world most exactly from his own intelligible and essential idea ; " so that it yet remains, as it was at first, perfect in beauty, and will never stand in need of any correction or improvement." There is no room for a caution here, to understand these expressions, not of any par- ticular circumstances of human life separately con- sidered, but of the sum or universal system of life and being. See also the vision at the end of the Theodicee of Leibnitz. Page 33, ver. 351. n This opinion, though not held by Plato, nor any of the ancients, is yet a very natural consequence of his principles. But the disquisition is too complex and extensive to be entered upon here. Page 43, ver. 726. 12 The reader wrill here naturally recollect the fate of the sacred battalion of Thebes, which at the battle of Chseronea was utterly destroyed, every man being found lying dead by his friend. Page 44, ver, 755. 13 The Macedonian, NOTES ON BOOK III. Page 47, Ver. 22. l The influence of the imagination on the conduct of life, is one of the most important points in moral philosophy. It were easy by an in- duction of facts to prove that the imagination directs almost all the passions, and mixes with almost every circumstance of action or pleasure. Let any man, even of the coldest head and soberest industry, analyze the idea of what he calls his interest 5 he will find, that it consists chiefly of certain images of decency, beauty, IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 75 and order, variously combined into one system, the idol which he seeks to enjoy by labour, hazard, and self-denial. It is on this account of the last consequence to regulate these images by the standard of nature and the general good ; otherwise the imagination, by heightening some objects beyond their real excellence and beauty, or by representing others in a more odious or terrible shape than they deserve, may of course engage us in pursuits utterly inconsistent with the moral order of things. If it be objected, that this account of things supposes the passions to be merely accidental, whereas there appears in some a natural and hereditary disposition to certain passions prior to all circumstances of educa- tion or fortune : it may be answered, that though no man is born ambitious, or a miser, yet he may inherit from his parents a peculiar temper or complexion of mind, which shall render his imagination more liable to be struck with some particular objects ; consequently dispose him to form opinions of good and ill, and enter- tain passions of a particular turn. Some men, for instance, by the original frame of their minds, are more delighted with the vast and magnificent, others on the contrary with the elegant and gentle aspects of nature. And it is very remarkable, that the disposition of the moral powers is always similar to this of the imagination : that those who are most inclined to ad- mire prodigious and sublime objects in the physical world, are also most inclined to applaud examples of fortitude and heroic virtue in the moral. While those who are charmed rather with the delicacy and sweet- ness of colours, and forms, and sounds, never fail, in like manner, to yield the preference to the softer scenes of virtue and the sympathies of a domestic life. And this is sufficient to account for the objection. Among the ancient philosophers, though we have several hints concerning this influence of the imagina- tion upon morals among the remains of the Socratic school, yet the Stoics were the first who paid it a due attention. Zeno, their founder, thought it impossible 76 NOTES ON THE PLEASURES OF to preserve any tolerable regularity in life, without frequently inspecting those pictures or appearances of things, which the imagination offers to the mind (Diog. Laert. I. xii.). The meditations of M. Aurelius, and the discourses of Epictetus, are full of the same senti- ments ; insomuch that the latter makes the Xprjmg ola del, (pavTaGiujv, or right management of the fancies, the only thing for which we are accountable to Providence, and without which a man is no other than stupid or frantic. Arrian. /. i. c. 12. and /. ii. c. 22. See also the Characteristics, voL i. from p. 313 to 321, where this Stoical doctrine is embellished with all the eloquence of the graces of Plato. Page 48, ver. 76. 2 Notwithstanding the general influence of ridicule on private and civil life, as well as on learning and the sciences, it has been almost con- stantly neglected or misrepresented, by divines espe- cially. The manner of treating these subjects in the science of human nature, should be precisely the same as in natural philosophy ; from particular facts to in- vestigate the stated order in which they appear, and then apply the general law, thus discovered, to the explication of other appearances and the improvement of useful arts. Page 49, ver, 84. 3 The first and most general source of ridicule in the characters of men, is vanity, or self applause for some desirable quality or possession, which evidently does not belong to those who assume it. • Page 50, ver. 121. 4 Ridicule from the same vanity, where, though the possession be real, yet no merit can arise from it, because of some particular circumstances, which, though obvious to the spectator, are yet over- looked by the ridiculous character. Page 5 1 , ver. 1 52. 5 Ridicule from a notion of excel- lence in particular objects disproportioned to their intrinsic value, and inconsistent with the order of nature. Page 51, ver. 179. 6 Akenside is supposed to have satirised Richard Dawes, Master of the Newcastle Grammar School, and author of Miscellanea Critica. IMAGINATION. BOOK III. 77 Page 52, ver. 191. 7 Ridicule from a notion of ex- cellence, when the object is absolutely odious or con- temptible. This is the highest degree of the ridicu- lous 5 as in the affectation of diseases or vices. Page 52, ver. 209. 8 Ridicule from false shame or groundless fear. Page 53, ver. 229. 9 Ridicule from the ignorance of such things as our circumstances require us to know. Page 54, ver. 258 10 By comparing these general sources of ridicule with each other, and examining the ridiculous in other objects, w7e may obtain a general definition of it, equally applicable to every species. The most important circumstance of this definition is laid down in the lines referred to ; but others more minute we shall subjoin here. Aristotle's account of the matter seems both imperfect and false ; rd yap yeXoTov, says he, l^\v a\idoTi}\xa tl tCj atcr^oc, clvlocvvov k} g'